The Extra Man is the definition of what many people call ‘quirky’. It takes the formula of the films from a short lived era (the ‘indie’ era; it takes a unique person who is not only an outsider to society, but likely out of place in this time period) and exploits it in a varying sense. Think of it as a sweetener; if someone is used to a lot of it, then large doses are fine (i.e. any fan of Wes Anderson or Noah Baumbach). However, the ‘quirk’ of the characters for many people will play their sugar levels up and down with most of them often finding it just a bit too sweet for their taste.
The film starts off with the awkwardness of the main character, Louise (Played by Paul Dano) coming into full bloom. I won’t allude to the nature of the awkwardness, but I must give the filmmakers credit for the original take on it. Louis is already strange enough before the incident; he models his life after characters from the novels of F. Scott Fitzgerald and studies the works of modernist literature. The personality of the character is a bit distracting at first, but in contrast to later character that will come about in the film, he acts as a palette cleanser; allowing the viewer to reset their tastes to something regular. Louis loses his job as a teacher, Louis decides to embark on a journey to live in New York as a writer.
This is where the film goes from being quaint to being a character study. The story turns its focus toward an old, washed up playwright, and future roommate of Louis’. A staunch Catholic and philistine, Henry Harrison becomes more the focus of the picture. He tells Louis of his profession; what he calls an ‘Extra Man’. He’s not a prostitute; rather, a younger escort for 90 year old billionaires and climbing up the social ladder. From there, you meet a slew of characters that go from grossly unreal (Otto, the Swedish humpback), to the realest (Mary Powel, a vegan urbanite who works for an eco magazine), to a long-playing-and-ultimately-worthless gag (Gershon, the silent ((sort of)) handyman). It’s just not enough, however. The film dies about midway through as the character of H.H. gets repetitive and boring and the other players all seem to lack humor or dramatic arc. The quiet moments of humor have reached their trough and the sweet taste from before has left a lingering note of burned oak and disappointment. Not only that, but most of the characters seem very static and lack change. One of the best moments in the film features a character realizing their lifestyle may not be the right choice, but that moment comes fast and leaves just as quickly.

There’s little else to be said about the film and, sadly, there is absolutely nothing memorable about it either. I found myself enjoying the film as it went on, but ultimately left the theater feeling the same as when I came in. However, how much can be said of that after this past movie season is left to question. What the film did do was give me a rush of excitement for the ‘indie’ film. Remember the good old days when films were quaint and unusual? I’m sure the filmmakers did as well. It’s honestly too bad they’re no longer desired. I can’t recommend or deter you from seeing this film in theaters. It is my honest opinion, however, that The Extra Man is a good film to have in your collection and pull out on a quiet and rainy day.
[Update: When you search for 'Extra Man' on Google, you get nothing but pictures of Katie Holmes. She's in the film a whole of 20 minutes.]

























