Posted on 15 October 2009.


I’m gonna go out on a limb here and admit that this review likely won’t stop you from going to see this movie. A movie, in Philly, starring Gerard Butler and Jamie Foxx is going to undoubtedly sell out to everyone man, woman, and irresponsible men and women who bring their children to see this surprisingly violent film. If you’d like to see a lot of blowing things up, people dying, puzzle solving, Jamie Foxx screaming, guy-from-300 naked, and action, then this is a pretty straight forward film and you probably won’t feel your money was wasted. But for those of us who like to enjoy our films we must avoid this movie at all costs. Here’s why:
Ever look at the trailer of this film, surmise the premise, and wonder “How are they gonna balance the differences between good and evil?”. Short answer: they don’t. It’s one of the many things that this film holds back on. It’s hard to dwell on the matter without divulging intimate details of the film’s climax, but suffice it to say this film is like sandpaper in the mouth of an audience member salivating for a reasonable resolution. **POSSIBLE SPOILER**

Not only that, but you feel a bit cheated. Instead of rounding out the characters and coming to a sound resolve of the situation, one ends up staring at a really pretty special effect. It’s like exchanging sugar for water.
Next up, is the writing. Most thrillers include unrealistic chases, convenient plot devices, and shallow character depth. Law Abiding Citizen switches the game up by doing all of these things when it had a good chance to avoid them easily. It relies pretty heavily on the change of Gerard Butler’s character from family man to killer, but when it bothers to tell us how he became such a proficient killer it fumbles. Time lines don’t add up and are not fully explained, the character’s morality (the basis of the entire plot) is never once questioned fully. It seems ironic that a story based around so much character change and development completely lacks in it. It actually works in a good way for part of the film in a sort of: “Real life doesn’t give way to moral affirmation at every turn” kind of way, but the situation is so extreme one may find it ridiculous for some of these characters not to have some cathartic moment. Something that can be looked at as both a fault and a positive thing within the film is that the audience will find itself either rooting for Butler or Foxx (most likely Butler) and will do so throughout the entire film. Sometimes, even when it’s obviously leaning toward one more than the other. Some audience members are gonna love this, some will be too busy rooting for their favorite character, and others will be frustrated at the flip flopping; seeing it more as an “on the whim” use of plot than the carefully calculated plot device it was.
The last thing that I found curious is the dynamic between Butler and Foxx. It will become obvious pretty early on in the film that the roles should have been reversed, maybe Foxx should have been replaced by someone with a little more enthusiasm for the project. But this likely would have caused a problem with race that would precede the film and hurt it in the box office. Well, without giving too much away, I can definitely see that. But, to be honest, it was a sacrifice that should have been made. It’s another case of this film holding back on being something potentially greater than the product we have today.
The bottom line is that this is a run of the mill, well paced, somewhat cookie cutter film. It does a good job of confusing the audience of who is right or wrong and keeping suspense, but without a conclusion that feels a bit compromised leaves the audience feeling empty. And, though it offers nothing new and tends to shoot itself in the foot in its narrative, it still managed to capture some of the audience members around me. Most of the acting is solid, the direction is great, and the technical aspect doesn’t rise over the bar but it also doesn’t go under. I’m not going to recommend going to see this film because I know you will anyway. As a word of advice: If you’re broke and have to choose between eating popcorn at this movie or eating a real meal, I’d choose dinner. Because there’s a 49% chance that, even though you’ll get a good jolt from a few of the scenes, you may not like this movie or you’ll at least feel like it wasn’t worth the money.
